Letter to the Judge
November 06, 2008
I was supposed to go to court today to plead to the judge to stop mr ex from harassing me, start paying me what he owes me, and stop preventing us from listing the house at a reasonable price. We came to an agreement during our mediation session on Tuesday so I will not have to go to court. (The post on that is still being mentally formulated but since I am so mentally drained, it’s taking some time.) But I thought that I would post the letter I had written to the judge at my lawyer’s behest. This letter would have been my opening argument in court.
* * *
I have been divorced from mr ex since August 2007. I have been separated from him since March 2005. It is unconscionable that we are still living in the same house.
I separated from him and divorced him because he is emotionally and verbally abusive. He has only gotten worse. Because we still live in the same house I am still an emotional and verbal punching bag for him. He has no stops on his mouth. He curses at me in front of our daughters, now 17 and 13. He insults me in front of them. It does not matter if I go into my room and close the door and lock it, he continues. It does not matter what I say or do, he continues. We are divorced, there is no reason for me to have to live in the same house as him.
We need to reduce the price of the house so that it can be sold. We will both still make money. I am being held prisoner because of his greed and my lack of money.
* * *
I have not slept in a bed since March 2005, except when visiting friends and family or on one weekend vacation. Since mr ex and I separated, I have slept on a couch in the living room, then on a mattress on the floor of the guest bedroom, and since June 2007 on a love seat.
That’s a lot of nights of discomfort.
That’s a lot of nights when I can’t stretch out.
That’s a lot of nights when I can’t roll around trying to find a comfortable spot so that I can go back to sleep.
That’s a lot of time for two girls, who are now both teenagers, but were 9 and 13 when we separated, to see their mother contorted on a love seat while their father stretches out on a king-size bed.
That’s a lot of time for two girls to see and hear their mother being verbally and emotionally abused.
That’s a lot of time for two girls to grow up watching what happens when love dies.
That’s a lot of time for two girls to think that this is normal.
We must sell this house. This is not a question of making money or losing money, this is an issue of not damaging our daughters even more. This is about not making me open game for his vile mouth any more just because he refuses to move, or to reduce the price of the house so that we can sell it.
I am being held prisoner in my own home.
Not only is this mental cruelty, but financially I am going further and further into debt every month. We purchased the home we are living in five years ago when mr ex’s annual salary was four times what mine is today. I am now expected to pay 50% of the expenses on this home on my teacher’s salary. I cannot afford to live in this house.
Not only that, but he does not abide by our PSA where it says he is supposed to pay 50% of the household expenses, and 50% of our daughter’s expenses. He has not purchased toilet paper for them in a year. He rarely buys food for them. He never pays me for the food I buy for them. He does not pay the bills. And if he does pay, it is always after late notices or disconnect notices arrive. For a year now he has not paid his share of his daughter’s expenses.
The only thing that he has done “for” his daughters is to try to make them hate me. He has repeatedly put me down in front of them or told them lies about me. He has called me a whore to them. He has called me a thief to them. He has called me a leech to them. He has told them I hate them. He has told them I don’t love them.
* * *
My bedless sleeping goes beyond that final separation in March 2005. In October of 2004 I first filed for divorce. At that time I had already been on the couch for a while. We decided to try to work on our marriage, but that did not last long since we permanently separated about five months later.
At around the same time that I told mr ex that the reconciliation is not working, and that I want to divorce (in March 2005), he lost his job. He asked me to wait until he finds a job before beginning the divorce process. I agreed. Who would have thought that it would take him a year and a half to find a job? And this a man whose job entailed networking. In that time we went through all of our savings.
When he did find a job in August/September 2006, he asked me to wait until he takes his license exams. He said that he couldn’t concentrate on both at the same time. Once again I agreed to wait.
Then in 2007 we finally divorced, at a time that was convenient for him. That was more than two years after we had separated. I had waited two years.
That was two years during which two girls saw their parents unable to communicate, and the already-bad situation between them disintegrate even more.
And now I am still waiting for the house to sell in order to move because I cannot afford to move otherwise. In that time the housing market has gotten worse, but not so bad that even if we severely cut the price of the home we wouldn’t still make a profit.
So I waited for two years for him to be settled into his new job. And now I have been asking him for many, many months to agree to reduce the price of the home so that it could hopefully be sold. And I am still waiting. And it is getting harder and harder. This is too unfair. This “life” is too steep a price for me to have paid, and for my daughters to have paid.
We separated in March 2005.
The house was put up for sale in June 2007.
It is now November 2008.
That is a long time. That is an eternity when you don’t know if you will be cursed out when you get home or when you get up in the morning. That is an eternity when you don’t know how you will afford to buy food for your daughters. That is an eternity when you keep getting “Cut Off” notices from the electric company. That is an eternity when you hear your daughters being told that you don’t love them. That is an eternity to regret marrying the wrong person. That is an eternity to cry yourself to a fitful sleep.
And if you think that we should have reached a livable impasse, you would be right, but that is not the situation.
On Saturday our younger daughter had her Bat Mitzvah. This is what he said to me on Sunday morning when I told him that I did not agree with him, that I do not agree with him taking her money and investing it. These comments were made in the presence of both of our daughters. They were made after I had already closed and locked my door, but he was in the hallway that linked all of our bedrooms, and they were in their rooms.
“I have a girlfriend.”
“Go fuck yourself.”
“This idiot.”
“Go away.”
“Liar.”
“Fucking asshole.
“You idiot. I'll cross examine you. You shit.”
“I never saw any money for college, you thief.” (This is in reference to money that my parents have saved for both of them.)
This is how he talks if he does not like what I say, or if I don’t want to do what he wants me to do. As I said, I divorced him because of this kind of behavior. Since we have not sold the house because of its high price—especially in this tough market—I am being continually harassed and abused. Not only that, but it generally happens in the presence of my daughters. Not only does this undermine my authority with them, but it demeans me, it makes them question me. Hopefully, too, it makes them question their father.
What kind of education in marital relations is this if this is all they see—have seen for years. This is cruel to them.
I separated and divorced so that they would not see their father continually abuse their mother. Unfortunately it did not work out that way.
No. They don’t see two people working on their marriage, or working on re-establishing their lives after a failed marriage.
No, they see one person continually harassing the other; they see one parent bullying the other parent. They see their father abuse their mother.
Later on Sunday, when the girls were not home, this is a portion of what he said to me:
“Fat”
“Dumbo the elephant”
“Loser”
He also accused me of attempting to kill him.
He said that one daughter called me evil and that the other daughter says horrible things about me.
I am divorced from this man, for good reason; I should not have to be in his presence. My daughters should not be exposed to his vile mistreatment of me.
* * *
This has been going on for years. It is enough.
He tells me that he will call the police if I touch the thermostat.
He told my father that he will call the police and have him arrested for trespassing when my parents came to visit me.
He has wished that my mother get cancer.
He accused me of attempting to murder him.
He has poisoned my daughters against me.
I have done everything that I can do. I have done everything that I am supposed to do. I have abided by all the laws and agreements. I cannot continue to be punished for that. I beseech you to please help rectify this situation.
(Maybe the judge on high will hear this and send down a miracle.)
I don't even know what to say. Wow. I hope the judge acts soon so you can get out of there and away from him. If you ever come to California, we have a spare room...
Posted by: JC | November 06, 2008 at 06:40 AM
JC, we didn't have to go to court, we came to an agreement in mediation. But sitting there, listening to him spin his yarns, which the mediator totally believed made me realize that at times we are really living in parallel universes. And I'm glad that I am out of his. How is it that people see, hear and interpret things so differently? Yes I know, boy/girl, but still, it's astonishing.
Posted by: Laura of Rebellious Thoughts of a Woman | November 06, 2008 at 03:33 PM
That is truly awful. I hope that you and your daughters can be rid of Ex soon.
Sadly, he sounds a lot like my ex. But I had no children involved and chose to be broke rather than spend another second in his presence.
Posted by: Christine | November 06, 2008 at 04:00 PM
Christine, who would have known it would be like this? Who can even imagine a worst case scenario when you are an honest, fair, reasonable person? If we didn't have kids, bye bye ages ago with a supreme slam of the door.
People are coming to see the house tomorrow--all appendages crossed!
Posted by: Laura of Rebellious Thoughts of a Woman | November 06, 2008 at 05:01 PM
But you're still having to live in the same house as that monster?? argghhh....that just makes me livid. I had a confrontation with my X today and it was over me sending him an email, asking a question. He told me it makes him angry(er) when I email instead of call and I told him I email to avoid "this" which was a shouting match where he talks over me and yells and tells me how much he wishes we didn't have to have any contact. I totally agree with that last part but because he won't communicate with me about our son, I have to contact him and ask questions. It's just a power ploy and he knows he's losing his grip so he tries anything to keep that hold over me. I feel your pain, girl. I really do.
Posted by: Midlife Slices | November 06, 2008 at 07:48 PM
But you're still having to live in the same house as that monster?? argghhh....that just makes me livid. I had a confrontation with my X today and it was over me sending him an email, asking a question. He told me it makes him angry(er) when I email instead of call and I told him I email to avoid "this" which was a shouting match where he talks over me and yells and tells me how much he wishes we didn't have to have any contact. I totally agree with that last part but because he won't communicate with me about our son, I have to contact him and ask questions. It's just a power ploy and he knows he's losing his grip so he tries anything to keep that hold over me. I feel your pain, girl. I really do.
Posted by: Midlife Slices | November 06, 2008 at 07:48 PM
I am SO sorry. I, too, divorced a man who was verbally and mentally abusive. I couldn't imagine if I had to continue living with him. I hope that with the decreased price, your house will sell lightning quick so you can get the heck out of there!
Posted by: Andrea's Sweet Life | November 07, 2008 at 05:58 AM
It's so important for children to be set an example by their parents. By standing up to this man you are setting that example, however hard it may feel.
They need to see you strong and empowered to live on your own. I hope that happens soon.
Posted by: Duchess | November 07, 2008 at 12:30 PM
MS, we too had the whole communication power play. I would not talk with him over the phone because of his shouts and used email. He did not like getting emails from Laura, so he cancelled that email account. And in a continuation of his doing everything you're not supposed to do in a divorce, he uses our daughters (and sometimes the realtor) to relay messages to me. Thanks so much, as always, for your support.
Sweet Life, what is with these men, who made them mini-gods? Oh, I forgot, their mothers. Yes, his mother set him as a little deity. He's probably not all her fault, but making a child feel that he is smarter and better than everyone else is probably not a sound basis for a compassionate person to emerge. I can't tell you how I am looking forward to living in a little apartment that is mine instead of this lovely house that feels haunted.
Duchess, I keep saying that to myself. While he may still be cursing at me, I divorced him, I stepped out of the relationship, I showed them that that kind of behavior is not okay. And hopefully my older daughter will someday realize that I am the one deserving of her respect and not him. Afterall, does fear really engender respect?
Posted by: Laura of Rebellious Thoughts of a Woman | November 08, 2008 at 06:30 AM
I still can't believe this nightmare has gone on as long as it has. You're an amazing woman!
Posted by: April | November 08, 2008 at 03:49 PM